Amazon released their list of the 100 Greatest Indie Rock Albums of All Times. As with any “definitive” list, Amazon’s has some flaws, and some seem to stand out like sore thumbs, especially moving from one individual’s taste to the next. As a side note, yes, Animal Collective’sÂ Merriweather Post Pavilion is a great album and will no doubt be at the top of many an end of the year list, butÂ isn’t it a bit too early to put it in the category of top anything of all time? I mean, the album came out two months ago…
The rules and regulations for the list were rather confusing, and when you consider the concept of indie rock vs independent rock music (many an early blues/rock label were, by way of creation, independent, but there’s not a mention of any Chess Records release or otherwise on the list), it’s all the more perplexing. And, the list does bring to light the confounding question of “is emo indie?” which seems to be brought up more often nowadays in a fashion sense than a musical sense. Still, a good chunk of emo produced today is independent and fits into the ambiguous aesthetic of “indie,” and in the past, emo was a strong component of the 90s emo scene.
Don’t believe it? Take a look at where some big-name emo acts landed on the Amazon list:
84.Â Hearts Of OakÂ – Ted Leo & The Pharmacists
83.Â Save YourselfÂ – Make Up
80.Â The Ugly OrganÂ – Cursive
78.Â Nothing Feels GoodÂ – The Promise Ring
45.Â How Memory WorksÂ – Joan Of Arc
31.Â Repeater + 3 SongsÂ – Fugazi
29.Â 24 Hour Revenge TherapyÂ – Jawbreaker
If you’re confused about the placement of some of these albums in relation to one another, you might not want to look at the full list… it’s rather… well, odd. But, I do have to give them some props for including The Promise Ring’s Nothing Feels Good… 33 1/3, take a look at that list!